Difference between revisions of "Whistleblower Protection Laws"

Line 315: Line 315:
See this helpful article in Accounting Today: [https://www.accountingtoday.com/opinion/whistleblower-protections-for-accountants-and-tax-professionals-bolstered-by-new-law Whistleblower protections for accountants and tax professionals bolstered by new law].
See this helpful article in Accounting Today: [https://www.accountingtoday.com/opinion/whistleblower-protections-for-accountants-and-tax-professionals-bolstered-by-new-law Whistleblower protections for accountants and tax professionals bolstered by new law].


Who is protected against retaliation under the Taxpayer First Act whistleblower protection law?
=='''Who is protected against retaliation under the Taxpayer First Act whistleblower protection law'''==
Section 1405(b) of the TFA prohibits any “employer, officer, employee, contractor, subcontractor, or agent” of an employer from retaliating against a whistleblower.  We have represented tax fraud whistleblowers at audit firms, private companies, public companies, and non-profits.
Section 1405(b) of the TFA prohibits any “employer, officer, employee, contractor, subcontractor, or agent” of an employer from retaliating against a whistleblower.  We have represented tax fraud whistleblowers at audit firms, private companies, public companies, and non-profits.


What whistleblowing is protected under the Taxpayer First Act?
=='''What whistleblowing is protected under the Taxpayer First Act?'''==
The TFA protects a broad range of disclosures about potential violations of IRS rules or tax fraud. It protects not only disclosures to the IRS, but also internal disclosures, including an employee’s disclosure to a supervisor or “any other person working for the employer who has the authority to investigate, discover, or terminate misconduct.”  In particular, protected conduct includes:
The TFA protects a broad range of disclosures about potential violations of IRS rules or tax fraud. It protects not only disclosures to the IRS, but also internal disclosures, including an employee’s disclosure to a supervisor or “any other person working for the employer who has the authority to investigate, discover, or terminate misconduct.”  In particular, protected conduct includes:


Line 325: Line 325:
(B) to testify, participate in, or otherwise assist in any administrative or judicial action taken by the Internal Revenue Service relating to an alleged underpayment of tax or any violation of the internal revenue laws or any provision of Federal law relating to tax fraud.
(B) to testify, participate in, or otherwise assist in any administrative or judicial action taken by the Internal Revenue Service relating to an alleged underpayment of tax or any violation of the internal revenue laws or any provision of Federal law relating to tax fraud.


Does the tax fraud whistleblower law protect only disclosures of actual tax fraud?
=='''Does the tax fraud whistleblower law protect only disclosures of actual tax fraud?'''==
TFA whistleblower protection is not limited to disclosures of actual tax fraud. Instead, DOL and federal court precedent construing similar whistleblower protection laws protect a whistleblower’s reasonable but mistaken belief that the conduct complained of constituted a violation of relevant law.  The whistleblower, however, must demonstrate that they had an objectively reasonable belief, which is assessed based on the knowledge available to a reasonable person in the circumstances with the employee’s training and experience.
TFA whistleblower protection is not limited to disclosures of actual tax fraud. Instead, DOL and federal court precedent construing similar whistleblower protection laws protect a whistleblower’s reasonable but mistaken belief that the conduct complained of constituted a violation of relevant law.  The whistleblower, however, must demonstrate that they had an objectively reasonable belief, which is assessed based on the knowledge available to a reasonable person in the circumstances with the employee’s training and experience.


What type of retaliation is prohibited against tax fraud whistleblowers?
=='''What type of retaliation is prohibited against tax fraud whistleblowers?'''==
The TFA prohibits a wide range of retaliatory personnel actions, including discharging, demoting, suspending, threatening, harassing, or in any other manner discriminating against a whistleblower in the terms and conditions of employment.
The TFA prohibits a wide range of retaliatory personnel actions, including discharging, demoting, suspending, threatening, harassing, or in any other manner discriminating against a whistleblower in the terms and conditions of employment.


The catch-all category of retaliation (“in any other manner” discriminating against a whistleblower) includes non-tangible employment actions, such as “outing” a whistleblower in a manner that forces the whistleblower to suffer alienation and isolation from work colleagues.  See Menendez v. Halliburton, Inc., ARB Nos. 09-002, -003, ALJ No. 2007- SOX- 5 (ARB Sept 13, 2011).  An employment action can constitute actionable retaliation if it “would deter a reasonable employee from engaging in protected activity.”  Id.at 20.
The catch-all category of retaliation (“in any other manner” discriminating against a whistleblower) includes non-tangible employment actions, such as “outing” a whistleblower in a manner that forces the whistleblower to suffer alienation and isolation from work colleagues.  See Menendez v. Halliburton, Inc., ARB Nos. 09-002, -003, ALJ No. 2007- SOX- 5 (ARB Sept 13, 2011).  An employment action can constitute actionable retaliation if it “would deter a reasonable employee from engaging in protected activity.”  Id.at 20.


What is the burden of proof for a tax fraud whistleblower in a TFA whistleblower retaliation case?
=='''What is the burden of proof for a tax fraud whistleblower in a TFA whistleblower retaliation case?'''==
Section 1405(b) of the TFA applies the causation standard and burden-shifting framework set forth in the AIR21 Whistleblower Protection Law.  Under that framework, the whistleblower prevails by proving that their protected whistleblowing was a contributing factor in the unfavorable personnel action taken by their employer.
Section 1405(b) of the TFA applies the causation standard and burden-shifting framework set forth in the AIR21 Whistleblower Protection Law.  Under that framework, the whistleblower prevails by proving that their protected whistleblowing was a contributing factor in the unfavorable personnel action taken by their employer.


Line 346: Line 346:
Once the whistleblower proves that their protected conduct was a contributing factor in the adverse action, the employer can avoid liability only if it proves by clear and convincing evidence that it would have taken the same adverse action in the absence of the whistleblower engaging in protected conduct.
Once the whistleblower proves that their protected conduct was a contributing factor in the adverse action, the employer can avoid liability only if it proves by clear and convincing evidence that it would have taken the same adverse action in the absence of the whistleblower engaging in protected conduct.


What remedies or damages can a whistleblower recover in a tax fraud whistleblower retaliation case?
=='''What remedies or damages can a whistleblower recover in a tax fraud whistleblower retaliation case?'''==


A prevailing TFA whistleblower is entitled to make-whole relief, which includes:
A prevailing TFA whistleblower is entitled to make-whole relief, which includes:
Line 356: Line 356:
These remedies are substantially similar to the relief authorized in the anti-retaliation provision of the False Claims Act.  Neither statute authorizes an award of punitive damages, but double back pay and uncapped special damages can be a potent remedy.
These remedies are substantially similar to the relief authorized in the anti-retaliation provision of the False Claims Act.  Neither statute authorizes an award of punitive damages, but double back pay and uncapped special damages can be a potent remedy.


What is the deadline or statute of limitations to file a tax fraud TFA whistleblower retaliation case?
=='''What is the deadline or statute of limitations to file a tax fraud TFA whistleblower retaliation case?'''==
The statute of limitations for a TFA whistleblower retaliation claim is 180 days from the date that the employee is first informed of the adverse action.
The statute of limitations for a TFA whistleblower retaliation claim is 180 days from the date that the employee is first informed of the adverse action.


Where are tax fraud whistleblower retaliation cases adjudicated?
=='''Where are tax fraud whistleblower retaliation cases adjudicated?'''==
The claim must be filed initially with OSHA, which will investigate the claim.  If OSHA determines that there is reasonable cause to believe that a violation occurred, OSHA can order relief, including reinstatement of the whistleblower.
The claim must be filed initially with OSHA, which will investigate the claim.  If OSHA determines that there is reasonable cause to believe that a violation occurred, OSHA can order relief, including reinstatement of the whistleblower.


Line 367: Line 367:
Yes.  TFA retaliation claims are exempt from mandatory arbitration.
Yes.  TFA retaliation claims are exempt from mandatory arbitration.


Can a whistleblower qualify for an award for reporting tax fraud to the IRS?
=='''Can a whistleblower qualify for an award for reporting tax fraud to the IRS?'''==
Under 26 USC § 7623(b), the IRS is required to issue an award to tax whistleblowers of 15% to 30% of proceeds collected from tax fraud or tax underpayments if:
Under 26 USC § 7623(b), the IRS is required to issue an award to tax whistleblowers of 15% to 30% of proceeds collected from tax fraud or tax underpayments if:


Line 375: Line 375:
During fiscal year 2018, the IRS awarded $312M to tax fraud whistleblowers, and whistleblowers enabled the IRS to recover $1,441,255,859.
During fiscal year 2018, the IRS awarded $312M to tax fraud whistleblowers, and whistleblowers enabled the IRS to recover $1,441,255,859.


Taxpayer First Act Whistleblower Protection Law
=='''Taxpayer First Act Whistleblower Protection Law'''==
26 U.S.C. § 7623(d)
26 U.S.C. § 7623(d)